TopLaw & Order
1990-Present
Season 2
Table of Contents
Confession
S02E01 1991
- In this episode, the viewer sees the death of Sergeant Max Greevey, but the actor who had played him in Season 1, George Dzundza, had already left the series. Here Greevey is played by a stunt double, who is only seen in the shadows and from the back.
- In most states the charge of murder in the first degree is charged for premeditated murder, murdering a person by lying in wait and murders committed during serious felonies, but in New York state it works a little differently. In New York premeditation & lying in wait are not aggravating factors and are charged as murder in the second degree. Murder in the first degree is reserved for: intentionally causing the death of a police or peace officer while performing their duties; intentionally causing the death of a firefighter, paramedic, EMT, physician or nurse responding to an emergency; intentionally causing the death of a judge or a person holding public office; intentionally causing the death of a witness to a crime in order to prevent them from giving a statement to the police or testifying before a judge or jury; murder for hire; murder for profit; causing the death of a person during the commission of a serious felony, such as kidnapping in the first degree, arson in the first degree, and rape in the first degree; intentionally causing the death of another person after being previously convicted of murder. Someone who is an active participant in a violent felony like arson, kidnapping, rape or robbery where someone is killed, even if they were not the one that caused the person's death, is charged with felony murder, which carries the same potential penalties as first degree murder.
- Sergeant Max Greevey (George Dzundza ), Assistant District Attorney's Claire Kincaid (Jill Hennessy ), and Alexandra Borgia (Annie Parisse ) are the only regular characters who are killed as part of an episode narrative. All the other regular characters either resign, are fired, or are transferred from their respective positions. Retired EADA Ben Stone's funeral was featured in Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (1999) episode The Undiscovered Country (2018).
- This episode appears to be based on the several different cases/incidents:
- The history of corruption in the American construction industry associated with the mafia.
- The 1982-1983 Oreste Fulminante case. In 1982, the 11-year-old stepdaughter of Oreste Fulminante was murdered in Arizona. Later, Fulminante was incarcerated for an unrelated miscellaneous charge. While in prison, Fulminante met Anthony Sarivola, his cellmate who was also a confidential informant for the Federal Bureau of Investigation. Sarivola offered Fulminante protection from "tough treatment" in prison in exchange for a confession to the murder of Fulminante's stepdaughter. Fulminante argued that the confession was invalid because it was coerced and he would have said anything to protect his own life. The confession was allowed in the first trial, but considered inadmissible in the appeal because of the confession was allegedly coerced.
- The 1963 Ernesto Miranda case. Ernesto Arturo Miranda was an American laborer whose criminal conviction was set aside in the landmark U.S. Supreme Court case Miranda v. Arizona, which ruled that criminal suspects must be informed of their right against self-incrimination and their right to consult with an attorney before being questioned by police. This warning is known as a Miranda warning. Miranda had been convicted of kidnapping, rape, and armed robbery charges based on his confession under police interrogation. After the Supreme Court decision invalidated Miranda's initial conviction, the state of Arizona tried him again. At the second trial, with his confession excluded from evidence, he was convicted. He was sentenced to 20-30 years in prison, but was paroled in 1972. After his release, he returned to his old neighborhood and made a modest living autographing police officers' "Miranda cards" that contained the text of the warning for reading to arrest's. Miranda was stabbed to death during an argument in a bar in Phoenix, Arizona on January 31, 1976. A Mexican man, Eseziquiel Moreno Perez, was charged with the murder of Miranda, but fled to Mexico and has never been located.
- Paul Sorvino joins the cast as Phil Cerreta in this episode.
- First appearance of Carolyn McCormick as clinical/forensic psychologist Dr. Elizabeth Olivet. She will be a long-time recurring character appearing in 87 episodes. She also appears in five episodes of Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (1999) and one episode each of Law & Order: Trial by Jury (2005) and Law & Order: Criminal Intent (2001).
- This episode premiered on September 17, 1991. Two incidents that were then prominent in the news are referenced. Ben Stone alludes to the Jeffrey Dahmer case, which broke in the news on July 22, 1991. And Adam Schiff references the Rodney King incident, which happened on March 3, 1991.
- This episode deals with the legal concepts of fruit of the poisonous tree and inevitable discovery. Any evidence that is obtained as the result of an illegal search or information from an illegally obtained confession, like the coerced confession Logan obtained, is considered fruit of the poisonous tree and therefore inadmissible as evidence in court. There is one exception to getting evidence obtained from illegally obtained information admitted into court, and that is inevitable discovery. If the prosecution can prove that evidence that had been declared fruit of the poisonous tree would have been found anyways by a separate, legitimate line of investigation, it then becomes admissible. Like the gun Cerreta and Logan found in the construction office for example, they found it because Magadan told Cerreta where it was after confessing, but since his confession was coerced the statement about the gun's location was tainted, thereby making the gun the product of an illegal search and inadmissible as evidence. However a judge had already signed a search warrant for that office prior to Magadan's confession, it just hadn't been executed yet. Since the police would have found that gun when they executed a search warrant, its legal discovery was inevitable, therefore making it admissible once again.
- Karen Shallo, the actress who played Marie Greevey, would go on to play two other characters in the series, before settling into the role of Arraignment Judge Anna Shiro (but called Judge Janet Shiro in her first appearance) from Stiff (2000) (season 10, episode 23) on-wards.
- With the introduction of Paul Sorvino, each of the front-four cast members shared either his first name or his character's first name with a different front-four actor or character:
The Wages of Love
S02E02 1991
- This episode appears to be based on several separate cases/incidents:
- The 1989 Elisabeth Broderick case. Five years after a very acrimonious divorce in the late 1980s, Broderick, a mother of four, purchased a revolver and broke into the home of her ex-husband (Dan) with a key that she had stolen from her elder daughter, Kim Broderick. She shot him and his second wife, Linda Kolkena, in their bed whilst they slept. In the years leading up to their deaths, Dan and Linda had felt so threatened by Betty they had even hired guards to protect themselves. Betty was convicted on 11 December 1991 of two counts of second-degree murder. She was later sentenced to 32 years to life in prison, with her first possible parole date in March of 2010.
- Partially ripped from the film Anatomy of a Murder (1959).
- Jerry Orbach tried out for the characters of Detective Sergeants Maxwell Greevey and Philp Cerreta, but he was passed over in favor of George Dzundza and Paul Sorvino, respectively. After playing the role of Frank Lehrman in this episode, Orbach replaced Sorvino in Season 3: Sorvino had decided he didn't care for the New York climate as he feared it would affect his singing voice. Orbach's gruff demeanor was so popular with the producers, they decided to replace Chris Noth's similar style (which they considered a lack of variety in characterizations) and have the younger character be more of a contrast to make Briscoe more prominent.
- Here playing Defense Attorney Frank Lehrman, this is the first appearance of actor Jerry Orbach in the vast "Law & Order" franchise. He would go on to play beloved long-running character, Detective Lennie Briscoe, from 1991 until he left the show seven months before his death from prostate cancer in 2004. Indeed, he appeared posthumously as DA Investigator Lennie Briscoe in 2 episodes of Law & Order: Trial by Jury (2005) spin-off that first aired in 2005.As Lennie Briscoe, he appeared in a further 273 episodes of the original "Law & Order" series alone. He also played Detective Briscoe in episodes of the Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (1999), Law & Order: Criminal Intent (2001) and "Law & Order: Trial by Jury" spin-off TV series, as well as voicing the role in 3 "Law & Order" video games.
- The concept of attorney-client privilege surviving death has been around for many decades, but for a long time was not considered to be a legally protected right in all of the United States until 1998. Prior to that most states had either laws or legal precedents making attorney client privilege survive death, it became a legally protected guarantee in New York when the New York Supreme Court ruled in 1987 that privilege survives death. But it wasn't until the 1998 case of Swidler & Berlin v. United States that the Supreme Court of the United States determined that privilege survives death, that it became a legal fact throughout the nation.
- The security guard said Mr. Cullen bought his .38 revolver after being denied a handgun permit. Since 1911, New York has required permits to own or carry handguns under the Sullivan Act, making it a "may issue" state where police have broad discretion in issuing permits. While ownership permits were easier to get, concealed carry permits were harder, requiring applicants to show specific need. Over time, these requirements became increasingly strict, prompting the New York Rifle & Pistol Association to sue, claiming violations of the Second and Fourteenth Amendments. The case reached the U.S. Supreme Court, which ruled on June 23, 2022, that "may issue" policies are unconstitutional. In a 6-3 decision, the Court mandated all states adopt a "shall issue" standard, requiring permits be granted to all qualified applicants.
- Robert Stanton has played four different roles over the course of the series:
- Melanie Cullen is charged with two counts each of murder in the first degree and manslaughter in the first degree in the murder of her husband and his mistress. This isn't done often, and is done when the circumstance, motive or intent of the defendant isn't clear, and it is left up to the jury to decide which type of homicide, if any, the defendant is guilty of. Murder in the first degree is charged when one person intentionally causes the death of two or more people in the same criminal act. However if a person commits a murder while suffering from an extreme emotional disturbance, like the kind which occurs when someone catches their spouse/lover having sex with someone else, that is considered a mitigating circumstance and reduces a murder charge down to voluntary manslaughter. So it will be up to the jury to determine if Mrs. Cullen killed her husband and his girlfriend, and if so was she suffering from emotional disturbance at the time. Requiring them to decide that Mrs. Cullen is either: guilty of murder in the first degree, OR not guilty of murder in the first degree but guilty of manslaughter in the first degree, OR not guilty of both charges.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Robert Stanton (Jed Knox) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode Going for the Gold (2013) (episode 4.15), as Peter Florrick & Hugh Saxon respectively.
- Robert Stanton and Colleen Cowan are credited as playing a married couple in this episode but their scenes must have been deleted.
Aria
S02E03 1991
- This is the first of 13 appearances of defense attorney Danielle Melnick, portrayed by Tovah Feldshuh. This character also appeared briefly in the final episode of Law & Order: Criminal Intent, To the Boy in the Blue Knit Cap (2011).
- Mrs. Blaine is charged with multiple types of homicide in her daughter's death: second-degree murder, first- and second-degree manslaughter, and criminally negligent homicide. Though rare, charging someone with several degrees of homicide is done when the exact motive or intent is unclear, leaving it to the jury to decide the level of culpability. ADA Robinette considered second-degree murder under the "depraved indifference" clause-where someone acts with extreme recklessness and ignores the risk of death. If the risk was only of serious injury, it's first-degree manslaughter; for general injury, second-degree manslaughter. If her actions were negligent but not reckless, it's criminally negligent homicide. The jury must choose one of the following: guilty of second-degree murder, or if not, guilty of first-degree manslaughter, or second-degree manslaughter, or criminally negligent homicide-or not guilty of all charges.
- Maura Tierney (Patricia 'Patti' Blaine) would later join the main cast as Lieutenant Jessica Brady in Season 24.
- The videotaped monologue left behind by Priscilla Blaine is essentially a reworking of a monologue spoken by the character of Jessie in Marsha Norman's 'Night Mother, where the primary metaphor is a bus trip, rather than a train ride.
- When EDA Ben Stone asks ADA Paul Robinette if he knows a good probate attorney, the scene immediately focuses on Tovah Feldshuh as Danielle Melnick. A Probate Attorney specializes in asset issues resulting from someone's death; Melnick became prominent in the series as a Defense Attorney.
- The actresses Maura Tierney and Lisa Nicole Carson went on to play Abby Lockhart and Carla Reese on ER (1994). They did not star together, however.
- This episode appears to be based on several separate cases/incidents:
- The 1962 death of actress Marilyn Monroe. Monroe (born Norma Jeane Mortenson) was found dead of a barbiturate overdose at her Los Angeles home on August 5, 1962, and her death was ruled a probable suicide by the coroner. Despite no evidence of foul play and a later review reaffirming the original findings, conspiracy theories involving political and organized crime figures have persisted for decades.
- The term "stage mother".
- Partially ripped from the pages of Mommie Dearest and its film adaptation (Mommie Dearest (1981)).
- Paul Sorvino and Frank Vincent are reunited after starring in Martin Scorsese's GoodFellas (1990), although they never shared screen time in that film.
- Tovah Feldshuh (Defense Attorney Danielle Melnick) and Michael Moriarty (EADA Ben Stone) previously appeared together in Holocaust (1978).
- The drug the victim overdoses on is amitriptyline, a tricyclic antidepressant, which is particularly dangerous drug to overdose on and much harder to treat than other drugs. While overdoses involving opioids or benzodiazepines are often survivable with prompt medical care, tricyclic overdoses have no specific antidote and can cause severe respiratory failure, dangerous heart rhythm disturbances, and serious effects on the nervous system.
- Vincent Curatola (Court Clerk) also played the role of Joey Dantoni, Sr. in Trade This (2000) (episode 10.16).
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) and Tovah Feldshuh (Defense Attorney Danielle Melnick) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode Doubt (2010) (episode 1.18) as Peter Florrick and Lena, respectively.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) and Maura Tierney (Patricia 'Patti' Blaine) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode And the Law Won (2012) (episode 4.2) as Peter Florrick and Maddie Hayward, respectively.
- Features two actors who later played heads of the New York mob in The Sopranos (1999): Frank Vincent and Vincent Curatola.
Asylum
S02E04 1991
- This episode is based on the 1987 David Mooney case. Mooney, a homeless man living under a New Haven highway ramp, was arrested for the strangulation murder of Yale-New Haven Hospital supervisor Theodore Genovese. Police found incriminating evidence among Mooney's belongings, but the case raised a landmark issue when homeless rights advocates argued the search violated the Fourth Amendment, asserting that homeless individuals have an expectation of privacy in their possessions.
- Lemonhead asks when Rehnquist will arrive, and Logan sarcastically says he's tied up with Supreme Court business-referring to William Rehnquist, one of the longest-serving justices in U.S. history. Rehnquist began as a Supreme Court clerk, later served as Assistant U.S. Attorney General under Nixon, and was appointed to the Court in 1972. He dissented in Roe v. Wade, believing abortion laws should be left to the states. In 1986, President Reagan appointed him Chief Justice, a role he held until his death in 2005. A conservative federalist, he favored limiting federal power over states and wrote key majority opinions in U.S. v. Lopez and U.S. v. Morrison. He also presided over President Clinton's 1999 impeachment trial.
- Tom Riis Farrell plays a homeless man in this episode. In Mayhem (1994) (episode 4.17), he portrayed Scott Hexter.
- Alex Draper played three different characters over the course of the series:
- A former colleague asks Stone why he stopped being a defense lawyer. He replies, "Defending the Nazis at Skokie didn't sit right with me," referring to the 1977 Supreme Court case National Socialist Party v. Skokie. The case involved Neo-Nazis planning a march through a largely Jewish community with many Holocaust survivors. Skokie tried to block the march, leading to a legal battle over First Amendment rights. The ACLU, ironically represented by a Jewish attorney, defended the Nazis; right to free speech and assembly. The U.S. Supreme Court ultimately ruled in favor of the marchers, emphasizing that even hateful speech is protected-a principle Stone found morally troubling.
- Christian "Lemonhead" Tatum, a homeless suspect, suffered from paranoid delusions, believing everyone was a CIA or KGB agent and that CIA headquarters was hidden beneath Central Park, where he claimed he had to meet William Casey. Casey was the real-life Director of Central Intelligence from 1981-1987, overseeing the CIA and the entire U.S. Intelligence Community during the Cold War. This community includes agencies like the NSA, DIA, and DHS Intelligence.Following the 2004 Intelligence Reform Act, the role of Director of Central Intelligence was split: the Director of National Intelligence (DNI) became head of the intelligence community, while a separate Director now leads the CIA and reports to the DNI. This change aimed to reduce the concentration of power and improve oversight.
- This is the first episode of the series not to display its title onscreen (previous episodes showed it before the guest stars).
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) and Tom Riis Farrell (Homeless man) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode Two Courts (2011) (episode 2.11) and the Law & Order: Criminal Intent (2001) episode The Good (2006) (5.22).
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) and Alex Draper (Nathan Robbins) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode The Death Zone (2011) (episode 3.2) as Peter Florrick & Joel Branch, respectively.
- Carolyn McCormick (Olivet) and Ron McLarty (Scoler) appeared together in Spenser: For Hire (1985).
- The Supreme Court recently ruled on the Fourth Amendment rights of homeless individuals, addressing privacy expectations and public camping laws. In Johnson v. City of Grants Pass (2024), the Court sided with the city, which had enforced ordinances banning camping on public property due to rising crime and unsanitary conditions. Homeless rights advocates challenged the ordinances and warrantless police searches of tents and trailers, citing the Eighth and Fourth Amendments. The Court ruled that being homeless does not exempt someone from trespassing laws and that police can search or remove dwellings in prohibited areas without a warrant. However, it clarified that in areas where public camping is allowed or not prohibited, the Fourth Amendment still applies and police must have probable cause or a warrant to conduct searches.
God Bless the Child
S02E05 1991
- This was Michelle Trachtenberg's television debut in the uncredited role of the child victim Dinah Driscoll, she would later play Willow Taylor on the Law & Order: Criminal Intent (2001) episode Weeping Willow (2006), which also starred Chris Noth as Detective Mike Logan. Michelle was best known for playing Dawn Summers on Buffy the Vampire Slayer (1997) and Georgina Sparks on Gossip Girl (2007). Sadly Michelle died on February 26, 2025 at the age of 39, due to complications following liver transplant surgery.
- This episode appears to be based on two separate cases/incidents:
- The 1989 Alex Dale Morris case. Alex, a four-year-old boy from Oregon City, Oregon, became seriously ill in February 1989. His parents, members of the Followers of Christ Church-a religious group known for rejecting medical treatment in favor of prayer-chose to treat his illness solely through spiritual means. Over a period of 46 days, Alex's parents and fellow church members prayed over him, anointed him with oil, and laid hands on him. Despite his worsening condition, no medical assistance was sought. On the 44th day, a police officer, acting on a tip, visited the home but left after Alex reportedly claimed he was feeling better. Two days later, Alex died. An autopsy revealed that an infection had filled one entire side of his chest with pus-a condition that could have been effectively treated with basic antibiotics.
- The 1989 Loren Williamson case. In June 1989, five-year-old Loren Don Williamson died of lymphocytic leukemia in Loranger, Louisiana. His mother, Annetta Williamson, a member of the Oak Grove Church of God, chose to rely solely on prayer and fasting for her son's treatment, adhering to her church's belief in faith healing. She did not seek any medical intervention for her son's illness. In 1990, Annetta Williamson was charged with negligent homicide, marking the first test of a Louisiana law that allowed parents to treat their children's illnesses exclusively through spiritual means. The trial garnered significant attention, highlighting the tension between religious freedom and child welfare. During the trial, the prosecution argued that Mrs. Williamson's failure to seek medical care constituted criminal negligence, leading to her son's unnecessary suffering and death. The defense maintained that she acted within her religious rights and sincerely believed in the efficacy of faith healing. After deliberating for nearly eight hours, the jury was unable to reach a unanimous verdict, resulting in a mistrial. The case underscored the challenges courts face when balancing constitutional protections of religious practices with the state's interest in protecting children's health and well-being.
- Marian Seldes who played the spiritual healer, went on to play Chris Noth's mother in Oh Come All Ye Faithful (1998). Her character was listed as "Mrs. Big," referring to the nickname of Noth's character Mr. Big.
- Socorro Santiago has played seven different characters over the course of the series:
- Socorro Santiago (Cora Amado) also played the role of Mami in Cruel and Unusual (1995) (episode 5.19). She would go on to voice Mami in the fourth season of Dora the Explorer.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) and Kenneth Tigar (Dr. Stanback) also worked together on three episodes of The Good Wife (2009) as Peter Florrick and Judge James Chase, respectively.
- Kenneth Tigar (Dr. Stanback) also plays the role of Dr. Sheldon Saperstein in Cost of Capital (2006) (episode 16.16) .
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) and Socorro Santiago (Cora Amado) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode Nine Hours (2010) (episode 2.9) as Peter Florrick and the Warden's secretary, respectively.
Misconception
S02E06 1991
- When Amy's boss told her that he would fire her if she didn't get an abortion, she threatened to go to the EEOC. EEOC stands for Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. This federal agency enforces the civil rights laws regarding workplace discrimination. The EEOC investigates claims of workplace discrimination based on a person's race, national origin, religion, sex, age, disability, sexual orientation, gender identity, and genetic information and on retaliation for reporting, participating in, and/or opposing a discriminatory practice.
- A 10-56 is the NYPD radio code to respond to a call for an ambulance. If someone calls 911 and requests an ambulance and the dispatcher notices that a patrol unit is in the vicinity of the call, the dispatcher will request that the patrol unit respond to the call to determine the extent of the person's injuries/illness and to also render any aid they can until the paramedics arrive on scene.
- Mike says, "Ours is not to question why, just pick up the garbage." He is paraphrasing a line from British poet Alfred Lord Tennyson poem of 1854 called "The Charge of the Light Brigade." ("Ours is not to reason why; Ours is but to do or die...") The poem details the events of the Battle of Balaclava during the Crimean War on October 25 1854. Britain and France were at war with the Russian Empire, and that battle was one of the bloodiest of the war.
- This episode appears to be based on two separate cases/incidents:
- The 1991 Maria Flores case. On March 1, 1991, Maria Flores, who was between 23 and 25 weeks pregnant, was shot in the chest during a robbery in San Diego. The assailant, 20-year-old Robert Davis, stole $378 from her purse. Flores survived the shooting after undergoing surgery; however, her fetus was stillborn the following day due to complications from the shooting, including blood loss and shock. The shooter, Robert Davis, was convicted of fetal murder under California law, but his conviction was later overturned on appeal due to unclear jury instructions about fetal viability. The case became a significant legal precedent in debates over fetal homicide and the definition of viability.
- The crime and legal statutes of fetal homicide.
- Molly Price has played four different roles over the course of the series:
- Ronnie Farer has played 3 different roles over the course of the series:
- New York State has multiple criminal charges related to unlawful abortion or causing the death of an unborn fetus:
- Self-Abortion (2nd Degree) - Class B misdemeanor: When a woman performs an abortion on herself without medical necessity or submits to one by an unlicensed person.
- Self-Abortion (1st Degree) - Class A misdemeanor: Same as above, but when the fetus is over 24 weeks.
- Issuing Abortional Articles - Class B misdemeanor: Providing drugs or tools used in an unlawful abortion.
- Abortion (2nd Degree) - Class E felony: Performing an unlawful abortion or causing fetal death through reckless acts.
- Abortion (1st Degree) - Class D felony: Performing an abortion after 24 weeks.
- Manslaughter (2nd Degree) - Class C felony: Causing the death of a fetus (over 24 weeks) or pregnant woman through reckless actions.
- Manslaughter (1st Degree) - Class B felony: Intentionally injuring a pregnant woman, unintentionally causing fetal death.
- Murder (2nd Degree) - Class A-I felony: Intentionally causing the death of a fetus past 24 weeks.
- Murder (1st Degree) - Class A-I felony (capital case): Intentionally killing a pregnant woman, knowing the fetus is over 24 weeks.
- Aggravated Murder - Class A-I felony (capital case): Premeditated, intentional, and cruel killing of a pregnant woman with intent to torture.
- Christopher Baylor, Amy Newhouse's boyfriend, is played by Reed Diamond, who will later play the character of Detective Mike Kellerman on Homicide: Life on the Street (1993). Even though it is not a Dick Wolf series, Homicide is considered a "sister" series and part of the Law & Order universe, with a few crossover episodes between the series including Sideshow (1999) and Baby, It's You (1997). Also the Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (1999) character of Detective John Munch, played by Richard Belzer, is actually an original character from Homicide; prior to transferring the NYPD's Special Victims Unit, Munch was a homicide detective with the Baltimore City Police Department.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) and Molly Price (Amy Newhouse) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode Everything Is Ending (2013) (episode 5.1) as Peter Florrick and Lena Cesca, respectively.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) and Ronnie Farer (Mrs. Marty Alcott) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode Innocents (2015) (episode 7.2) as Peter Florrick and Vera Toll, respectively.
- Actress Molly Price, who portrays Amy Newhouse, also appeared in two episodes of Sex and the City (1998), which starred Chris Noth, who portrays Detective Mike Logan in this episode.
In Memory Of
S02E07 1991
- This episode appears to be based on several separate cases/incidents:
- The 1990-1991 George Franklin case. In September 1969, Susan Nason disappeared from her hometown of Foster City, California. Her body, discovered outdoors a few months later, showed signs of a violent death, including a crushed skull and a smashed ring that seemed to indicate she was warding off a blow. A bloodstained rock was found nearby. Police never made an arrest for her murder. Twenty years later, during an hypnosis session in the early 1990s, Eileen Franklin claimed that she remembered repressed memories of being with Susan Nason and her father George on the day of the murder. Eileen said that she had watched her father rape and kill Susan and that he had threatened her, Eileen, too. Franklin was initially convicted of first-degree murder, but the conviction was overturned once the court learned that Eileen was hypnotized prior to recovering this memory and that Eileen's recollections matched erroneous newspaper accounts rather than the true series of events.
- The 1924-1928 Albert Fish (a.k.a. "The Gray Man") case. Fish was serial killer, rapist, child molester and cannibal who committed at least three child murders between July 1924 and June 1928. He was a suspect in at least ten murders during his lifetime, although he only confessed to three murders that police were able to trace to a known homicide. He also confessed to stabbing at least two other people. Fish once boasted that he "had children in every state", and at one time stated his number of victims was about 100. However, it is not known whether he was referring to rapes or cannibalization, nor is it known if the statement was truthful. Fish was apprehended on December 13, 1934, and put on trial for the kidnapping and murder of Grace Budd. He was convicted and executed by electric chair on January 16, 1936, at the age of 65.numerous other crimes involving children and was executed in 1936.
- The 1970-1973 Dean Corll (a.k.a. "The Candy Man") case. Corll, infamously known as "The Candy Man," was a serial killer who, between 1970 and 1973, abducted, raped, tortured, and murdered at least 28 boys and young men in Houston and Pasadena, Texas. He earned his nickname from his family's candy business, where he was known for giving free candy to local children. Corll was aided by two teenage accomplices, Elmer Wayne Henley and David Owen Brooks, who helped lure victims to his home with promises of parties and drugs. Once there, the victims were restrained, assaulted, and killed. The crimes came to light when Henley fatally shot Corll in 1973, leading to the discovery of the victims' bodies buried in various locations. Henley and Brooks were subsequently convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment. The case, known as the Houston Mass Murders, remains one of the most horrific serial murder cases in U.S. history.
- The 1963-1968 Stanley Rice case. Rice was an American serial killer and child rapist who was responsible for sexually abusing numerous underage boys in Canada and the U.S. during the 1960s, of which he killed at least three. Tried and convicted for one murder committed in Florida, he was sentenced to life imprisonment and remained incarcerated until his death in 2007.
- The controversial recovered-memory therapy practice. Recovered-memory therapy (RMT) is a catch-all term for a controversial and scientifically discredited form of psychotherapy that critics say utilizes one or more unproven therapeutic techniques (such as psychoanalysis, hypnosis, journaling, past life regression, guided imagery, and the use of sodium amytal interviews) to purportedly help patients recall previously forgotten memories. Proponents of recovered memory therapy claim, contrary to evidence that traumatic memories can be buried in the subconscious and thereby affect current behavior, and that these memories can be recovered through the use of RMT techniques. RMT is not recommended by mainstream ethical and professional mental health associations.
- Logan says that there is no statute of limitations on a homicide, while that isn't technically wrong it isn't accurate either. The state of New York has 16 different types of criminal homicide, only three of those charges have no statute of limitations. The charges of abortion in the second degree, abortion in the first degree, vehicular manslaughter in the second degree, vehicular manslaughter in the first degree, aggravated vehicular homicide, criminally negligent homicide, manslaughter in the second degree, and manslaughter in the first degree have a statute of limitations of 5 years. The charges of aggravated criminally negligent homicide, aggravated manslaughter in the second degree, and aggravated manslaughter in the first degree also usually have a statute of limitations of 5 years, but since they involve the death of a police officer certain circumstances can increase the time limitations. Only the homicides of murder in the second degree, murder in the first degree, and aggravated murder have no statute of limitations.
- Adam LeFevre has played seven different characters over the course of the series:
- Thad Messimer's former co-worker said they weren't fired but signed a mutual termination agreement. This type of agreement allows both the employee and employer to part ways on good terms. The employee may receive severance or retirement benefits, and in return, agrees not to sue. Reasons for such agreements vary-from amicable job changes or company restructuring to underperformance or misconduct that could harm the company's reputation. In some cases, it's used to quietly remove employees involved in unethical or illegal behavior without public fallout.
- It was once a widespread misconception that gay men were more likely to be pedophiles, especially with male victims. A 1970 survey found over 70% of Americans believed gay men shouldn't work with children. However, FBI data from 1970-2005 shows that heterosexual men are 11 times more likely than gay men to commit sex crimes against minors. While gay offenders exist, they make up a small fraction of child molesters. It's also untrue that gay offenders only target boys. Among gay pedophiles (those attracted to children under 10), victims were nearly evenly split between boys and girls. Higher male victim rates appeared only among those attracted to older children (ages 11-19). Still, gay offenders targeting children under 12 are extremely rare. This mirrors patterns among straight offenders: the younger the victim, the less gender preference is shown; the older the victim, the more defined the preference (e.g., straight men targeting teens usually go after girls). Female offenders are much rarer, with lesbian abusers being especially uncommon. True female pedophiles are almost nonexistent; most female offenders target teens-straight women usually boys, and lesbians girls-with rare exceptions.
- Murder and all class A felonies in New York have no statute of limitations. This includes crimes like predatory sexual assault, terrorism, first-degree kidnapping, arson, and major drug trafficking. Some class B felonies-such as first-degree rape, incest, and aggravated sexual abuse-also have no time limit for prosecution. Certain class C and D felonies, including second-degree sexual crimes, can be prosecuted within 20 years of the crime or 10 years from when it was reported. Third-degree sexual offenses (class E felonies) have a 10-year limit. All other class B-E felonies not listed have a 5-year statute of limitations. Misdemeanors must be charged within 2 years, and violations within 1 year.
- Recovered memory testimony was allowed in U.S. courts from the 1980s to early 2000s but was later disallowed after a 1988 rape conviction was overturned. The conviction relied heavily on the victim's recovered memories under hypnosis and circumstantial evidence, but DNA testing in 1999 proved the semen didn't match her father. Instead, it matched a convicted serial rapist who lived nearby. It was found her therapist's bias led to false memories. Following this case, many convictions based on recovered memories were reviewed, with over half proven false. Courts then stopped accepting such testimony in criminal cases, though it may still be used in civil suits.
- Actor Vincent Pastore can be seen sitting in the courtroom.
- According to this story, the boy disappeared in 1962, his skeleton being found with a JFK for president button. Although JFK only ran for president in the years before being elected in November 1960, and prior to his 1963 death, presumably the boy was wearing an old button supporting the man who had become president.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) and Adam LeFevre (Joseph Kelly) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode I Fought the Law (2012) (episode 4.1) as Peter Florrick and Judge Gregory Kakissis, respectively.
Out of Control
S02E08 1991
- This episode appears to be based on two separate cases/incidents:
- The 1990 St. John's University lacrosse case. The case involved allegations of sexual assault against several members of the men's lacrosse team. On March 1, 1990, a 21-year-old African American female student reported that she was sexually assaulted by six white male students, including five lacrosse players, at an off-campus house in Jamaica, Queens. She stated that after being given an alcoholic drink, she became semi-conscious and was assaulted at two different locations. The case garnered significant media attention and sparked debates on race, consent, and campus culture. During the trial, one student, Thomas Dean, pleaded guilty to second-degree sexual abuse and testified against the others. The remaining defendants were acquitted of all charges, with the jury citing inconsistencies in the victim's testimony and questions about consent. Despite the acquittals, a university disciplinary committee recommended the expulsion of three students involved, citing conduct unsuitable for members of the university community.
- The 1990 David Lallemand case. In October 1990, University of Rhode Island student Michelle Eckman reported she had been raped at a fraternity party and identified David Lallemand from a photo lineup as her attacker. Based on her identification, campus police obtained a warrant and arrested Lallemand. At his bail hearing, Eckman could no longer identify him, and the charges were dismissed; a grand jury declined to indict. Lallemand then sued the university police under civil rights law, claiming false arrest and inadequate investigation. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit held that the arresting officer had probable cause at the time of arrest based on the victim's initial positive identification, so the officer was entitled to qualified immunity and Lallemand's lawsuit was dismissed.
- EADA Stone doubts he can prove first-degree rape since there were no witnesses and the victim was too drunk to recall details or say "no." DA Schiff says if first-degree can't be proven, they should show the victim was too impaired to consent, making a case for second-degree rape. In New York, first-degree rape involves forcible compulsion or when the victim is physically helpless. With no memory or witnesses, proving this is tough. Second-degree rape applies if the victim is mentally incapacitated-like being drunk-making consent invalid. The victim's blood alcohol was .12%, enough to impair judgment legally. First-degree rape (class B felony) carries 5 to 25 years, while second-degree (class D felony) carries 2 to 7 years prison. Proving second-degree is easier but still serious.
- Sexual abuse is classified into three degrees often used in plea deals:
- Third-degree sexual abuse involves non-consensual sexual contact (fondling intimate areas like anus, breasts, genitals, or ejaculating on the body). It's a class B misdemeanor with up to 90 days jail and a $500 fine.
- Second-degree sexual abuse is sexual contact with someone unable to consent due to mental incapacity or under age 14. It's a class A misdemeanor punishable by up to 1 year jail and a $1,000 fine.
- First-degree sexual abuse involves sexual contact by force, with a physically helpless person, or with someone under 13 (or under 11 regardless of age). It's a class D felony with 2-7 years prison and a $5,000 fine.
Note: Rectum, urethra, and vagina are excluded from sexual abuse definitions because penetration of these areas is classified separately as aggravated sexual abuse, a more serious crime. - Paul Sorvino has a brief conversation with Welker White, they both appeared in the movie GoodFellas (1990).
- Joe Grifasi plays the part of Ezra Gould in this episode, He would later go on to play the part of James Linde in Corpus Delicti (1996) (episode 6.11), Cherished (1998) (episode 9.1) and Deep Vote (2001) (episode 11.24).
- Brian Tarantina has portrayed three different characters over the course of the series:
- A young Isaiah Washington plays the fraternity VP in this episode.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Nestor Carbonell (Stuart Carradine) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode The Deep Web (2014) (episode 5.20), as Peter Florrick & Daniel Irwin respectively.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Brian Tarantina (Corso) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode The Penalty Box (2012) (episode 3.21), as Peter Florrick & Frankie Peel respectively.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Joe Grifasi (Ezra Gould) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode Judged (2016) (episode 7.13), as Peter Florrick & Judge John Mata respectively.
Renunciation
S02E09 1991
- This episode appears to be based on the 1990 Pamela Smart case. In Derry, New Hampshire, in 1990, 22-year old Smart who at the time was a high school media coordinator, manipulated her 15-year-old lover Billy Flynn into murdering her 24-year-old husband Greg Smart, promising Flynn they would have a future together. Along with his friends Patrick Randall, Raymond Fowler, and Vance 'J.R.' Lattime Jr., Flynn shot Greg Smart execution-style and then made the scene look like a botched robbery. During the trial, all four boys turned against Pamela Smart, who was dubbed "Ice Princess" by the media due to her behavior. Pamela Smart is now serving a life sentence in New Hampshire for accomplice to first-degree murder, conspiracy to commit murder, and witness tampering .
- Stone says he can't charge Jenna Kealey because she didn't break the law, but she actually did-multiple times. She could be indicted for third-degree rape and criminal sexual act for having oral sex and intercourse with a 16-year-old boy. New York law requires prosecutors to file statutory rape charges when there's proof or admissions from both parties. Each sexual act counts as a separate charge-for example, if Jenna and Roy had several encounters in one day, she'd face multiple counts: three for criminal sexual act and two for rape. Both are violent class E felonies, punishable by fines, probation, and 1-4 years in prison per count. Conviction on all five counts would guarantee prison time, with a maximum of 20 years and possible parole after five.
- This episode is set before the Sex Offender Registration Act of July 5, 1995. After the act, someone like Jenna Kealey, who had sex with a 16-year-old, would be:
- A Level I (low risk) sex offender. Level I offenders, often convicted of misdemeanor or third-degree felony sex crimes, must register for 20 years, update their address yearly, and photo every three years. Their exact residence isn't public, only city and zip code via hotline.
- Level II (moderate risk) offenders usually have second-degree felony convictions, must register for life, update address yearly, and photo every three years. Their full address is public. They can petition for removal after 30 years if no violations occur, unless labeled a predicate offender, sexual predator, or violent sexual offender.
- Level III offenders (high risk) commit serious sex crimes, often against children. They must register for life, check in every 90 days, update photos yearly, and their full info is public with notifications to victims and schools when they move.
Sex offenders can also be designated as predicate offenders (previous sex crime), sexually violent offenders (force involved), or sexual predators (violent offenses with serious victim harm and high re-offense risk). Violent offenders and predators are at least Level II. Level III sexual predators must wear GPS monitors for life; removing the device illegally leads to life imprisonment without parole. - Stephen Singer has played six different characters over the course of the series:
- Sam Coppola (Bartender) also played the part of U.S. Federal Judge Vance in City Hall (2004) (Season 14, Episode 14).
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Bernie McInerney (Judge Michael Callahan) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode Death Row Tip (2011) (episode 3.8) and Law & Order: Criminal Intent (2001) episode Wasichu (2006) (episode 5.14).
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Stephen Singer (Aaron Gerstein) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode Poisoned Pill (2010) (episode 2.6), as Peter Florrick & Dr. Nathan Elias respectively.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Sam Coppola (Bartender) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode Great Firewall (2011) (episode 2.16), as Peter Florrick & Merrick respectively.
- Richard Brooks had a part in The Good Wife (2009) episode Targets (2016) (episode 7.15) with Chris Noth.
Heaven
S02E10 1991
- This episode appears to be based on several separate cases/incidents:
- The 1990 Happy Land Social Club Fire caused by Cuban refugee Julio Gonzalez. On March 25, 1990, Gonzalez poured a gallon of gasoline at the only exit to an illegal Bronx social club, which resulted in the deaths of 87 people. The few who survived jumped through the flames, one of whom was the intended victim of the crime--Gonzalez's girlfriend, Lydia Feliciano.
- The 1980 Denmark Place fire in Central London. The fire, caused by arson, killed 37 people of eight nationalities. Most of the victims were Spanish or Latin Americans, and were patrons of two unlicensed bars in the building. At the time, The Sunday Times said the fire could be "the worst mass murder in British history".
- The 1911 Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire in the Greenwich Village neighborhood of Manhattan, New York City.
- The Rudolph Lee case. Winston v. Lee was a decision by the U.S. Supreme Court, which held that a compelled surgical intrusion into an individual's body for evidence implicates expectations of privacy and security of such magnitude that the intrusion would be "unreasonable" under the Fourth Amendment, even if likely to produce evidence of a crime.
- On the wall of the INS office, and its seal, is the Latin phrase "Qui Pro Domina Justitia Sequitur". This is the motto of the Department of Justice and means "who prosecutes on behalf of Lady Justice".
- The episode title "Heaven", or "El Cielo", was the name of the club that was burned down.
- Guerra says he is willing to plead to one count of conspiracy to defraud the government, which is a class E felony that can either result in a $1,000 fine and five years probation or a sentence of 1-4 years in prison. Stone says there is no way he is pleading to a single minor charge, that the indictments against him are going to be hundreds of pages long and the best he can hope for in exchange for cooperating is a sentencing recommendation. At this Guerra makes a sarcastic remark to his lawyer in Spanish, which translates to "this man speaks for the devil".
- Some fire victims had forged green cards costing $3,000-over 3,300% more than the legitimate 1991 INS fee of $90. By 2025, green card costs rose to $700 for Immigrant Alien Worker cards, $1,140 for Permanent Residence, and $3,675 for Entrepreneur cards. After 9/11, the INS was disbanded and its duties moved to the Department of Homeland Security. Now, USCIS issues green cards, while INS functions split among USCIS, ICE, and CBP. Other agencies like the Coast Guard, FEMA, Secret Service, and TSA also joined DHS.
- Normally, a death caused during arson is charged as first-degree murder, but this case is an exception. New York charges depraved indifference homicides as second-degree murder, while other states call it first-degree manslaughter. Guerra and Collins said they only meant to scare people, not kill, and there was no proof against that. To charge Collins with first-degree murder, the state must prove intent to kill, which they can't. However, setting fire to a building full of people is clearly a grave risk to life. When someone knowingly disregards such risk without intent to kill, it's depraved indifference. In New York, killing under depraved indifference is second-degree murder-the only case where murder charges don't require intent to kill.
- When Stone says that Roberto Diaz was the first Latino on fraternity row, he replies they hadn't seen many Latinos in New Hampshire. This suggests they may have attended Dartmouth University, located in Havover, New Hampshire.
- Phyllis Somerville (Kristen Cameron, Head Nurse) previously played the role of Ms. Maltese in Subterranean Homeboy Blues (1990) (Episode 1.2).
- Tom Tammi has played four different characters over the course of the series:
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Tom Tammi (James Collins) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode Landing (2016) (episode 7.19), as Peter Florrick & Carroll McGuire respectively.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Phyllis Somerville (Kristen Cameron) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode The Deconstruction (2015) (episode 6.20), as Peter Florrick & Louise Nolfi respectively.
His Hour Upon the Stage
S02E11 1991
- The title is taken from William Shakespeare's "Macbeth": "Life's... but a poor player / That struts and frets his hour upon the stage...."
- This episode appears to be based on two separate cases/incidents:
- The 1983 Roy Radin murder case. Radin was a theatrical producer best known for reviving old vaudeville shows. On Friday, May 13, 1983, Roy Radin stepped into a limousine rented by Karen Greenberger with the intention of going to a restaurant and further discussing a business arrangement. About a month later, his body was discovered in a California canyon. He had been repeatedly shot in the head, and a stick of dynamite had been set off in his mouth. The story behind Radin's death was a labyrinthine tangle, mostly involving drugs. Greenberger turned out to be a woman of many names and interests. Although producer Robert Evans was initially suspected of the crime, Greenberger was eventually convicted.
- The 1922 William Desmond Taylor case. On February 2, 1922, the prominent silent film director was found dead in his Los Angeles bungalow, having been shot in the back. The crime scene was compromised when studio executives and actors arrived before the police, and a man posing as a doctor incorrectly declared the cause of death as a stomach hemorrhage. The investigation uncovered Taylor's concealed past-he was born William Cunningham Deane-Tanner and had abandoned his wife and child years earlier. Several Hollywood figures became suspects: actress Mabel Normand, who was the last known person to see Taylor alive; young star Mary Miles Minter, whose love letters were found in Taylor's home; and Minter's mother, Charlotte Shelby, who allegedly owned a rare .38-caliber pistol similar to the murder weapon and was rumored to have threatened Taylor. Despite extensive media coverage and speculation, no one was ever charged, and the case remains officially unsolved. The scandal tarnished the reputations of those involved and led to the implementation of Hollywood's first morality clauses in actor contracts, aiming to restore the industry's image.
- The victim in this episode is a Broadway producer who was putting on a play titled 'Bleak House.' Bleak House is a novel written by Charles Dickens in the 1850's.
- Tony Darrow and Mike Starr both were in GoodFellas (1990), although they didn't share any scenes. Like in Goodfellas, Tony plays a restaurant owner associated with the mob.
- Dylan Baker has portrayed three different characters throughout the series:
- The car salesman makes some common mistakes, which Cerretta corrects. He says, "Cadillacs are as American as Columbus," but Cerretta replies, "Columbus was Spanish, Cadillacs are Italian." Columbus, a Spanish noble, never actually discovered North America-he landed in the Bahamas in 1492 and was later arrested for cruelty to natives. The first Europeans to reach North America were Vikings, 500 years earlier. Erik the Red settled Greenland in 982, and his son Leif Erikson landed around 1000 AD in what is now Newfoundland, Canada, calling it Vinland. Vikings found Native Americans already living there-descendants of Asians who migrated across a frozen land bridge about 20,000 years ago. While Cadillacs are owned by American company GM, their design and some bodies came from the Italian firm Pininfarina, with models like the Allanté, Skylight Coupe, and Eldorado Brougham built in Italy and shipped to the U.S. for assembly.
- Logan complains about widespread assault rifles and calls for banning machine guns, but Cerretta tells him to "write your congressman." As a police officer, Cerretta should know that New York banned civilian machine gun purchases in 1986 under the Firearm Owners' Protection Act (FOPA), except for those registered before then. Fully automatic firearms have been tightly regulated since the 1934 National Firearms Act (NFA), which requires buyers to file forms, pay a $200 tax, and pass thorough background checks. Since 1986, new machine guns can only be owned by military, law enforcement, or licensed dealers/manufacturers/importers with special occupational taxes, making civilian ownership rare, expensive, and heavily monitored. The NFA also regulates short-barrel rifles, sawed-off shotguns, and suppressors. Each Title II firearm purchase requires separate approval and tax stamps. Despite strict laws, over 99.9% of crimes involving these firearms use illegally obtained weapons. In 2016, New York banned civilian possession of all Title II firearms, including those legally owned, requiring surrender or sale within 90 days, and outlawed new purchases of semi-automatic rifles with detachable magazines. NYC imposes even stricter rules. However, these laws have done little to reduce shootings or violent crime.
- Hunt offers to cooperate if he is allowed to plea to hindering prosecution in the third degree, but ADA Robinette says the deal on the table is hindering prosecution in the second degree, and the deal becomes void if he lies about anything. Hindering prosecution in the third degree is when a person renders criminal assistance to another person that has committed a felony, it is a class A misdemeanor with a punishment of a fine of up to $1,000 and potentially up to one year in jail. Hindering prosecution in the second degree is when a person renders criminal assistance to another person that has committed a class B or class C felony, it is a class E felony that carries a fine of $1,000 and a sentence of either five years probation or a prison sentence of 1-4 years. Hindering prosecution in the first degree is when a person renders criminal assistance to another person that has committed a class A felony, it is a class D felony with a fine of $3,000 and a minimum sentence of two years in prison with a potential maximum of seven years.
- John Cunningham has played five different characters over the course of the series:
- William Hill has portrayed seven different characters throughout the course of the series:
- Frank Converse has played five different roles over the course of the series:
- Walter Bobbie has played three different roles over the course of the series:
- Stone notes that besides New York state charges, Cobb could face federal charges under Title 18 of the United States Code, the main federal criminal code. Title 18 covers federal crimes and procedures across five parts: Part I details federal crimes like arson, assault, and murder; Part II covers criminal procedures such as arrests and sentencing; Part III manages the federal prison system; Part IV addresses juvenile offender procedures; and Part V sets rules for witness immunity, allowing testimony without self-incrimination under the Fifth Amendment by granting immunity from prosecution for their own crimes mentioned in testimony.
- As Logan (Chris Noth) and Cerreta are discussing the case, Logan makes reference to Josh Foster as "Mr. Big dreams." Chris Noth goes on to play "Mr. Big" in Sex in the City who is a "major dreamboat" according to Carrie.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Dylan Baker (Sean Hyland) also worked together on six episodes of The Good Wife (2009) as Peter Florick & Colin Sweeney respectively.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & William Hill (Hopkins) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode Closing Arguments (2011) (episode 2.23) and Law & Order: Criminal Intent (2001) episode Players (2007) (episode 6.17).
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & John Cunningham (Cobb) also worked together on Feeding the Rat (2011) (episode 3.4), as Peter Florrick & Gene Osterman respectively.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Walter Bobbie (Peter Cummins) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode Runnin' with the Devil (2013) (episode 4.16) as Peter Florrick & Seth DeLuca respectively.
Star Struck
S02E12 1992
- This episode appears to be based on three high-profile stalking cases involving actresses:
- Rebecca Schaeffer, who was stalked and then shot dead by Robert Bardo, who obtained her address through DMV records, prompting the passage of anti-stalking laws in California. Schaeffer was best known for her role in the sitcom My Sister Sam (1986).
- Theresa Saldana, the stalking victim of Arthur Richard Jackson, a 46 year old drifter from Aberdeen, Scotland. Jackson stabbed her in the torso 10 times, with a 5 1/2 inch knife, near the front of her home in broad daylight, almost killing her. Saldana recovered after 4 hours of surgery, and a 4-month hospital stay. It was later revealed that he had hired a private investigator to obtain her mother's phone number.
- Andrea Evans, who dropped out of public view for nearly a decade. Years later she revealed that she had left to escape a persistent stalker who became too familiar with her schedule and kept showing up at the set, and had later gone as far as breaking into the ABC studios in New York City, intent on killing her.
Also inspired by the following two cases/incidents:
- The assassination of John Lennon by Mark David Chapman. On December 8, 1980, outside the Dakota apartment building in New York City, Mark David Chapman, a 25-year-old former security guard from Hawaii, shot Lennon four times in the back as the former Beatle returned home with his wife, Yoko Ono. Earlier that day, Lennon had autographed an album for Chapman. Chapman, who remained at the scene reading a copy of The Catcher in the Rye, later said he was driven by a desire for fame and resentment toward Lennons perceived hypocrisy. He pleaded guilty and was sentenced to 20 years to life in prison, where he remains. Lennons murder shocked the world and led to an outpouring of grief from fans globally.
- The Birgit Nilsson stalking case involving Nell Theobold. In 1966, Nell Theobald, an American model and aspiring actress, suffered a traumatic incident when she was mauled by a lion during a BMW photo shoot at the New York International Auto Show. She later received a substantial financial settlement from the incident. Following this, in 1968, Theobald became fixated on Swedish opera singer Birgit Nilsson after attending one of her performances at the Bayreuth Festival. This obsession led Theobald to stalk Nilsson for nearly a decade. In 1977, after her financial resources were depleted, Theobald attempted suicide in a hotel room adjacent to Nilssons in Vienna. A few months later, she died by suicide in a motel in Queens, New York.
- Last in-person acting role for Werner Klemperer.
- Title drop: The newspaper Captain Cragen is reading while the credits are displayed has the episode title "Star Struck" as a headline.
- Allison Janney makes her first appearance in the series. She would make a second and more prominent appearance in Old Friends (1994) as a different character, Ann Madsen.
- This episode represents a nifty bit of casting references to WWII-themed shows. First, Blanche Baker and Michael Moriarty appeared in the miniseries Holocaust (1978). Moriarty played a Nazi officer, and Baker played a Jewish prisoner in Auschwitz, condemned to death in the gas chambers. Werner Klemperer was perhaps most famous for his portrayal of Colonel Klink in Hogan's Heroes (1965). In addition, although Klink was a German officer, Klemperer himself was a Jew, as were three of his fellow actors in HH who were also featured prominently as German officers. Baker, Moriarty, and Klemperer all won Emmys for their respective portrayals in Holocaust and Hogan's Heroes.
- Mr. Unger asks Stone if he has children, but Stone doesn't answer. It's later revealed he has two: Pamela, who has schizophrenia, and Peter, a recurring character in the Law & Order universe. Peter shared his father's interest in law but was also a talented baseball pitcher. After a shoulder injury ended his pro baseball dreams, he finished law school and worked as a prosecutor in Chicago, eventually becoming Deputy Chief of Special Prosecutions. Peter first appeared in the short-lived series Chicago Justice (2017). He later came to New York for Stone's funeral, felt connected to his father for the first time, and was offered a Senior ADA job by DA Jack McCoy. Peter accepted and became a regular in season 19 of Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (1999).
- Jesse Unger's lawyer references defending John Hinckley Jr., who attempted to assassinate President Ronald Reagan in 1981. Hinckley was obsessed with actress Jodie Foster, inspired by her role in movie Taxi Driver (1976), and believed killing Reagan would win her affection. He fired six shots, seriously injuring Reagan and wounding others. Charged with multiple felonies including attempted murder of the president, Hinckley was found not guilty by reason of insanity and spent 1982-2016 in a mental institution. Press Secretary James Brady, paralyzed by the shooting, died decades later from related complications, which were ruled a homicide. Hinckley stalked Foster at Yale, sending letters and calls. After failing to get her attention, he planned the assassination. He originally targeted Jimmy Carter but was stopped at the airport with weapons and fined $50. Later, after learning Foster disliked Reagan, he believed killing Reagan would impress her.
- David Drake played three different characters during the course of the series:
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Julie White (Sandy) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode Dark Money (2015) (episode 6.13), as Peter Florrick & Selma Krause respectively.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & David Drake (Voorman) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode Blue Ribbon Panel (2012) (episode 3.19), as Peter Florrick & Jacques respectively.
- Dr. Olivette missed an opportunity to further prove that Jesse Unger was mentally fit to stand trial, and was lying about hallucinating and hearing voices. Unger's father testified that Jesse claimed to hear voices in his head, telling him things like the world was going to blow up in a nuclear war, or telling him to do bad things. Jesse claiming to hear voices in his head is a dead giveaway that he is lying. When trying to determine whether someone is actually hearing voices, or just faking to get attention or appear crazy for a jury, psychiatrists and psychologists ask one simple question: "is the voice in your head?"; those faking always say that it is. Those that are telling the truth will say the voices come from outside them, many often describe it as if they are hearing the voice of a ghost, a spirit, or an invisible person in the same room with them they can't see. Which is what makes real hallucinations so frightening, and can cause the person hallucinating to potentially be a danger to themselves or others; to the person experiencing them they seem absolutely real, to them the voices they are hearing or sights they are seeing are indistinguishable from reality.
Severance
S02E13 1992
- This episode appears to be based on the 1982 Donald Nash case. In 1982, Irwin Margolies hired Donald Nash to kill Margaret Barbera and Jenny Soo Chin, who were cooperating with a Federal investigation into Margolie's $5.7-million-dollar fraud. On January 5 1982, Nash succeed in killing Chin, whose body was never found. On April 12, Nash would kill Barbera and also kill Leo Kuranuki, Robert Schulze, and Edward Benford--three CBS-TV technicians who the police believed were coming to Barbera's aid. Barbera's body was found in Manhattan the next morning. Nash was convicted of four counts of second-degree murder and a single count of conspiracy, and he was sentenced to 100 years in prison. Margolies was sentenced to 50 years for ordering the murders.
- When Detectives Phil Ceretta and Mike Logan arrest Larry Teasdale, Logan tells him he's under arrest for bribery, witness tampering and conspiracy to commit murder, with Ceretta saying "I think the good councilor knows his rights" and then cuffs him without reading him his rights. As redundant as it might sound police are required to read everyone their rights when arresting them, even if the person being arrested is an attorney or judge who clearly knows what their rights are. If Teasdale had said anything incriminating after being arrested without being Mirandized, the judge would not allow it to be used in evidence, despite the fact the judge knew that Teasdale was well aware of his right to remain silent.
- This episode shares its title with the Season Twenty-One episode Severance (2022).
- J. Smith-Cameron has played four different characters over the course of the series:
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Joe Urla (Defense Attorney Werner) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode The Last Call (2014) (episode 5.16), as Peter Florrick & Kurt respectively.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & J. Smith-Cameron (Ms. Moskowitz) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode Restraint (2015) (episode 7.08), as Peter Florrick & Samara Steel respectively.
Blood Is Thicker...
S02E14 1992
- When one of the detectives says Ryder was in the National Guard during the Vietnam War, he says Ryder was in "the Dan Quayle brigade." Dan Quayle was a politician who served in the House of Representatives from 1977 to 1981; a U.S. Senator representing Indiana from 1981 to 1989; and, from 1989 to 1993, the 44th Vice President of the United States, serving under President George H.W. Bush. In 1969, Quayle joined the Indiana National Guard and used his family's political connections to ensure that he was stationed state-side and not sent into combat in Vietnam. Once that became public knowledge, the term "Dan Quayle brigade" was used to describe any person that was drafted and used any wealth or political influence they might have to get out of serving in a combat unit.
- Ryder is re-arrested and has his bail revoked after trying to flee to Barbados, claiming he wanted to take his family away from the media. The court saw this as an attempt to avoid prosecution. In 1992, Barbados-then a UK Commonwealth constitutional monarchy-had no extradition treaty with the US, making it difficult to bring Ryder back if he had escaped there. Since the 1970s, many US criminals fled to Caribbean nations like Barbados and the Bahamas to avoid prosecution amid the US war on drugs and organized crime. This led to new extradition treaties: the Bahamas signed one in 1990, Barbados in 1996, and a broad UK-US treaty in 2003 covering all UK Commonwealth nations.
- John Bedford Lloyd has played three different roles over the course of the series:
- This is one of actor Nicholas Turturro's (Poletti the parking lot attendant) early credits, later in his career he would play NYPD officers and detectives that were recurring or main characters on a number of series. These include the characters of: Detective James Martinez on NYPD Blue (1993), Sergeant Anthony Renzulli on Blue Bloods (2010), and Detective Frank Bucci on Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (1999).
- Sam Freed played three different roles over the course of the series:
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) and Sam Freed (Kent Meeker) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode Invitation to an Inquest (2013) (episode 4.17), as Peter Florrick and Dale Dazzo, respectively.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) and John Bedford Lloyd (Jonathan Ryder) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode The Last Call (2014) (episode 5.16), as Peter Florrick and Bob Klepper, respectively.
Trust
S02E15 1992
- This episode appears to be based on several separate cases/incidents:
- The 1986 Rod Matthews case. In 1986, 14-year-old Rod Matthews of Massachusetts murdered his classmate Shaun Ouillette after luring him to a remote area and bludgeoning him with a baseball bat. Matthews had told friends for months he wanted to know what it felt like to kill someone. He later bragged about the crime and showed others the body, leading to an anonymous tip that exposed him. Arrested and convicted, [as of 2019] Matthews remains in prison for the murder.
- The 1989 Barbara Stager case. Stager was convicted of murdering her husband, Russell Stager, in 1989 in Durham, North Carolina. She claimed the shooting was accidental, but investigators found it was a calculated act driven by financial motives, including life insurance. It was later discovered that her first husband had also died under suspiciously similar circumstances. She was sentenced to life in prison.
- The 1872 Jesse Pomeroy (a.k.a. "The Boston Boy Fiend") case. Pomeroy, known as "The Boston Boy Fiend," was a teenage murderer who shocked 19th-century America. Born in 1859, he began torturing younger boys at age 12 and was briefly institutionalized. After his early release, he murdered two children-10-year-old Katie Curran and 4-year-old Horace Millen-in 1874. At just 14, Pomeroy was convicted and sentenced to death, but due to his age, the sentence was commuted to life in solitary confinement. He died in custody in 1932. His case raised enduring questions about juvenile justice and mental illness.
- Ceretta notes a child got hold of a handgun and ammo, leading to another child's death, and says someone should be charged. This spurred New York's 2019 Safe Storage Gun Law, requiring firearms to be stored unloaded with a trigger lock or in a safe when not under the owner's control. Violations are class A misdemeanors, punishable by up to $1,000 fine and one year in jail. Parents can face extra charges if a minor uses an improperly stored gun in a crime.In Michigan (2021), a school shooter's parents were charged with involuntary manslaughter after their son, Ethan Crumbly, killed four students. The parents ignored his mental health issues and gave him access to guns, resulting in 10-15 year sentences. In Georgia (2024), Colin Gray became the first parent charged with murder after his son killed four at school with an AR-15 Colin gave him. Colin faces multiple charges, including second-degree murder and cruelty to children, as prosecutors deemed his actions willfully indifferent to student safety.
- The ballistics expert claims single-action revolvers are only for competition, which is inaccurate. While many are used in competition, they're also popular with hunters and collectors, as most Old West revolvers were single-action (e.g., Colt .45 Peacemaker). The murder weapon is a Ruger Security Six, a double-action, but Ruger also makes well-known single-action revolvers like the Single Six, Bearcat, Blackhawk, Vaquero, and Super Blackhawk, used for hunting, target shooting, and historical appeal.
- The judge barred Stone from using Jamie's prior shooting to challenge his claim that he didn't understand how a double-action revolver works, ruling it more prejudicial than probative. However, Stone could have impeached Jamie through his father, Ian. Ian told detectives he was a competitive handgun shooter who taught Jamie to shoot and sometimes brought him to matches. Competitive shooting involves single- and double-action revolvers, making it implausible that Jamie wouldn't understand how a double-action works. A responsible firearms instructor would have explained all of a revolver's functions, as failing to do so could cause exactly the kind of incident Jamie described.
- The ballistics examiner says the murder weapon fired a wadcutter bullet, which Ceretta notes is usually for target practice. Wadcutter bullets have a flat nose the same diameter as the caliber, designed to cut clean holes in paper targets for precise scoring. They use lighter powder for less recoil and quieter, subsonic speeds, ideal for indoor ranges and competition shooting. Recently, hard cast wadcutters-made from a lead alloy and coated with polymer-have been developed for self-defense in large revolvers (.44 Magnum and up). These bullets don't expand but penetrate deeply into soft tissue and bone (they do not penetrate body armor) and are used mainly for hunting or defense against large animals like bears and elk.
- Lizbeth Mackay has played three different roles over the course of the series:
- The music video playing in Jamie Maser's room when the police speak to him is "She's Gone" by the band Steelheart.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) and Lizbeth Mackay (Pamela Maser) also worked together on Sticky Content (2014) (episode 6.09), as Peter Florrick and Sandra, respectively.
Vengeance
S02E16 1992
- At the end of this episode, EADA Ben Stone mentions the death of a "Richard Speck" in prison. Richard Benjamin Speck was incarcerated at the Stateville Correctional Center in Illinois for the rape-torture murders of eight student nurses on July 13 and 14, 1966. He died of a heart attack December 5, 1991, at the age of 49 while serving a life sentence that had been commuted from death.
- This episode appears to be based on several mass murder cases including:
- The 1962-1964 Albert DeSalvo (aka "The Boston Strangler) case. DeSalvo, known as the "Boston Strangler," confessed to killing 13 women in Boston between 1962 and 1964, though he was only imprisoned for rapes. His confession has long been disputed, with theories suggesting multiple killers. In 2013, DNA evidence linked him conclusively to the murder of Mary Sullivan, confirming his role in at least that crime.
- The 1966 Richard Speck case. Richard Benjamin Speck was an American mass murderer who systematically raped one and tortured and murdered eight student nurses from South Chicago Community Hospital on the night of July 13 into the early morning hours of July 14, 1966. He was convicted at trial and sentenced to death, but the sentence was later overturned due to issues with jury selection at his trial. Speck died of a heart attack in 1991, after 25 years in prison. In 1996, videotapes featuring Speck were shown before the Illinois State Legislature to highlight some of the illegal activity that took place in prisons.
- The 1950's Harvey Glatman (aka "The Lonely Hearts Killer"/"The Glamour Girl Slayer") case. Harvey Murray Glatman was an American serial killer active during the late 1950s. He would use several pseudonyms, posing as a professional photographer to lure his victims with the promise of a modeling career. He was found guilty of two counts of first-degree murder and sentenced to death, a sentence that he accepted willingly. He specifically asked the warden to do nothing to save his life. He was executed in the gas chamber of San Quentin State Prison on September 18, 1959.
- The 1987 Timothy Wilson Spencer (aka "The Southside Strangler") case. He was an American serial killer who committed three rapes and murders in Richmond, Virginia, and one in Arlington, Virginia, in the fall of 1987. In addition, he is believed to have committed at least one previous murder, in 1984, for which a different man, David Vasquez, was wrongfully convicted. He was known to police as a prolific home burglar. Spencer became the first serial killer in the United States to be convicted on the basis of DNA evidence, with David Vasquez being the first to be exonerated following conviction on the basis of exculpatory DNA evidence.
- The 1971-1979 Rodney Alcala (a.k.a. "The Dating Game Killer") case. Alcala was an American serial killer and sex offender who was sentenced to death in California for five murders committed between 1977 and 1979, receiving an additional sentence of 25 years to life after pleading guilty to two further homicides committed in New York State in 1971 and 1977.
- The 1974-1991 Dennis Rader, the BTK (Bind, Torture, Kill) killer which was active during the filming of this episode. Convicted of 10 murders but suspected of twice that many, Rader terrorized Wichita, Kansas . A sexual sadist and narcissist, he started as a crossdresser and voyeur, breaking into neighbors' homes to steal clothes. His signature was binding, torturing, and sexually abusing victims-often reviving them before killing. Victims ranged from 9 to 63 years old, including two children and three men he called "collateral damage." He taunted police with letters for decades but wasn't caught until 2005, when a floppy disk he sent revealed his identity via metadata. Facing the death penalty, Rader pled guilty, confessed without remorse, and was sentenced to 10 consecutive life terms with parole eligibility after 175 years.
- Michael Moriarty and Jay Patterson previously worked together in Tailspin: Behind the Korean Airliner Tragedy (1989).
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) and Matt Malloy (CSU Technician) also worked together in The Good Wife (2009) episode In Sickness (2011) (episode 2.21), as Peter Florrick and Kevin Haynes, respectively.
Sisters of Mercy
S02E17 1992
- This episode appears to be based on two separate cases/incidents:
- The Covenant House scandal of 1990, involving Bruce Ritter. In 1990, Bruce Ritter was forced to resign from Covenant House after widespread reports that he had engaged in sexual relations with several young boys in the care of the charity and that financial improprieties had occurred in the operations of the organization. At that time, it was one of the most widely publicized cases of sexual abuse within the Catholic Church, which in subsequent years would be revealed to have been even more widespread. Ritter left the Franciscans, but he retained his priestly faculties. He retired to a small town in upstate New York.
- The McMartin 1983-1990 preschool trial. A highly publicized and controversial case in California involving allegations of child sexual abuse at a Manhattan Beach preschool. It began when a parent accused staff of abusing her child, sparking a wide-ranging investigation and mass hysteria. Dozens of children made bizarre claims, including satanic rituals, but no physical evidence was ever found. After years of trials, all charges were dropped or resulted in acquittals. The case is now seen as a cautionary tale of moral panic and flawed investigative techniques.
- Three of the guest stars of this episode appeared in medical TV shows. William H. Macy starred as Dr Morgenstern on ER (1994), Kate Burton starred in Grey's Anatomy (2005) as Ellis Grey and Judy Reyes played nurse Carla Espinoza on Scrubs (2001).
- Kate Burton plays Sister Bettina in this episode. She goes on to play the role of Erica Gardner in four later episodes.
- Mark Zimmerman has played five different characters over the course of the series:
- Vincent Laresca (Danny) also played the role of Feo Ruiz In The Brotherhood (2004) (episode 15.03).
- William H. Macy and Kate Burton also guest starred in the Spenser: For Hire (1985) episodes If You Knew Sammy (1987) and Play It Again, Sammy (1988) along with Sal Viscuso.
- A young Judy Reyes (Maria) appears as Maggie's (Kelli Williams') roommate in this episode.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) and Kate Burton (Sister Bettina) also worked together on three episodes of The Good Wife (2009) as Peter Florick and Victoria Adler, respectively.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Vincent Laresca (Danny) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode Breaking Up (2011) (episode 2.10), as Peter Florrick & Detective Navarro respectively.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Mark Zimmerman (Polygraph Tester) also worked together on The Good Wife (2009) episode Tracks (2016) (episode 7.12), as Peter Florrick & Ned Venters respectively.
- A young Kelli Williams stars in this episode and is at the beginning in the cafe threatening to commit suicide.
Cradle to Grave
S02E18 1992
- This episode appears to be based on two separate cases/incidents:
- The 1990 Brittany Eichelberger case. In December 1990, 3-year-old Brittany Eichelberger from Elkins, West Virginia, was found lifeless in a snowdrift after wandering outside her home in freezing temperatures. Her core body temperature had dropped to 74°F, and her heart had stopped. Through prolonged CPR and warming efforts, medical personnel revived her. Despite initial concerns about frostbite and potential brain damage, Brittany made a remarkable recovery and was walking and talking within weeks. Her survival is considered a medical miracle.
- The main character of Iris Corman appears to be based on Leona Helmsley--a.k.a. "The Queen of Mean"--a notorious New York City property owner who committed tax evasion in 1982.
- NYC Housing Authority investigators call Iris Corman New York's "Scum Lord of the Year" for three years running. The city maintains a Top 100 Worst Landlords list, awarding the worst the title "Most Infamous Landlord of the Year." As of 2024, Daniel Ohebshalom, who owns five Washington Heights properties, is the leading contender for "World Landlord of the Decade." He's been on the Top 100 list for over a decade, with two consecutive years as Most Infamous Landlord. Ohebshalom faces over 3,300 violations for heating issues, mold, pests, and structural hazards, plus tenant harassment. Two of his buildings were condemned in 2023 after he ignored court orders to fix them. He was jailed for up to 60 days until repairs were made. In 2024, he was indicted on multiple felony and misdemeanor charges, facing 9 to 38+ years in prison, likely serving concurrent sentences.
- Bill Cwikowski has played seven different roles over the course of the series:
- John Speredakos has played four different characters over the course of the series:
- Tom Alan Robbins (Ed Kushner) also played the role of Gary in Episode 11.24, Shattered (2010).
- Carol Woods (Ms. Price) also played the role of Polly Fairfield in Extended Family (1993) (Episode 3.11).
- A young Chandra Wilson (Serena) plays as the babysitter to the infant.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & John Speredakos (Dr. Orton) also worked together in Cuba Libre (2003) (episode 2.9), as Peter Florick & a Death Row guard respectively.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Carol Woods (Ms. Price) also worked together in Red Team, Blue Team (2013) (episode 4.14), as Peter Florrick & Margaret Lorenzo respectively.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Bill Cwikowski (Hampton) also worked together in Whack-a-Mole (2013) (episode 5.9), as Peter Florrick & Ronald Keyser respectively.
The Fertile Fields
S02E19 1992
- This episode appears to be based on several cases/incidents:
- The Crown Heights Riot of 1991. The Crown Heights Riot was a 3--4 day riot that began on August 19 in the Crown Heights neighborhood in the New York City borough of Brooklyn. A Rabbi Schneerson--a prominent Hasidic Rabbi--was returning from a regular visit to his father-in-law's grave. When crossing through an intersection, [another car in the rabbi's entourage] was hit by another car. The struck car veered out of control, hitting and killing a 7-year-old Guyanese youth, Gavin Cato. Following this incident, numerous acts of violence were committed against Jewish citizens in the area. One historian described the riot as "the most serious anti-Semitic incident in American history."
- The 1977 Pinchos Jaroslawicz case. In 1977 in New York City's Diamond District, Jewish diamond broker Pinchos Jaroslawicz, 25, was killed by Israeli immigrant Shlomo Tal and an accomplice. They lured Jaroslawicz to Tal's office, where he was murdered and his body concealed in a wooden box. The crime highlighted tensions between traditional diamond dealers and newer entrants to the industry.
- The 1972 Michelle Confait case. Maxwell Thomas Berty Confait, also known locally as Michelle and "Handbag", was a 26-year-old Seychelles-born cross-dresser who was murdered in London, England, on either 21 or 22 April 1972. The investigation into Confait's death and the convictions of three youths based on confessions of dubious validity raised questions about police procedures in the United Kingdom and caused a major review in how police treat suspects, particularly minors and the "educationally subnormal".
- Partially ripped from the 1991 crime film Homicide (1991).
- First episode to feature Leslie Hendrix as Dr. Elizabeth Rodgers, the Chief Medical Examiner for New York County; Hendrix played Rodgers in 143 episodes between 1992-2010. Hendrix also appears as Rodgers, along with Chris Noth, in the TV movie Exiled (1998), which is about Mike Logan after he gets "exiled" to Staten Island; Rodgers also appears in 9 episodes of Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (1999), 110 episodes of Law & Order: Criminal Intent (2001) (including after Logan gets transferred to Major Case), and in one episode of Law & Order: Trial by Jury (2005).
- Because this episode involves members of a Jewish community, the title of this episode is a possible reference to a phrase found in the Torah/Old Testament. The phrase "fertile fields" is used several times in Ezekiel and Genesis. For example, "It was in a fertile field, by the side of a wide stream that the vine had been planted, to branch out and bear fruit and become a noble vine." And guessing that the title is used ironically, considering the tragic end of the story. [01.25.2019]
- First episode to feature David Lipman as recurring character Judge Moodie. In future appearances, he would also play Judge Morris Torledsky, a character who also appears on Law & Order: Trial by Jury (2005). Lipman also plays recurring character Judge Arthur Cohen in Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (1999).
- William Hill has portrayed nine different characters throughout the course of the series:
- Jerry Stiller (Michael Tobis) also played the role of Sam Pokras in the episode Deadbeat (1996).
- Sharrieff Pugh (Fontaine) also played the role of Marcus in the episode 12.09, 3 Dawg Night (2001).
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & William Hill (Hopkins) also worked together on the The Good Wife (2009) episode Closing Arguments (2011) (episode 2.23) and the Law & Order: Criminal Intent (2001) episode Players (2007) (episode 6.17).
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Jerry Stiller (Michael Tobis) also worked together on Silver Bullet (2011) (episode 2.15), as Peter Florrick & Judge Felix Afterman respectively.
- ADA Robinette says Jacob's lawyer filed a writ of mandamus, a court order forcing officials to perform a legal duty or stop illegal actions. Historically, writs were used in civil rights cases and later challenged handgun bans in Washington D.C. and Chicago, leading to the 2008 U.S. v. Heller ruling that struck down such bans as unconstitutional.
- A young Daryl Mitchell appears on this episode as (Reggie) the youth that is beaten.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Sharrieff Pugh (Fontaine) also worked together on Getting Off (2011) (episode 2.22), as Peter Florrick & Ben Glavis respectively.
- This is actor David Lipman's first appearance in the series. This is the only time that he doesn't play Judge Torledsky.
Intolerance
S02E20 1992
- This episode appears to be based on several separate cases/incidents:
- The 1991 Wanda Holloway case. Holloway was a Texas mom who asked her brother-in-law to hire a hit man--a hit man who was to kill the mother of a girl competing with her daughter for a spot on a Texas cheerleading squad. After a second trial, Holloway pleaded "no contest" to attempted murder. The judge found Holloway guilty and sentenced her to ten years in prison. She was released on March 1, 1997, after serving six months of her sentence. The event was later made into two films Willing to Kill: The Texas Cheerleader Story (1992) and The Positively True Adventures of the Alleged Texas Cheerleader-Murdering Mom (1993).
- The 1991 University of Iowa shooting. On November 1, 1991, in Iowa City, Iowa, Gang Lu, a 28-year-old former graduate student in physics, killed five people and critically injured another before taking his own life. Lu's motivation stemmed from his belief that his doctoral dissertation had been unfairly overlooked for the prestigious D.C. Spriestersbach Dissertation Prize, which was awarded to his former roommate, Linhua Shan. Lu had written letters outlining his grievances and intentions, which were discovered posthumously.
- The 1932 Massie Trial. Thalia Massie, a white Navy wife, claimed she was assaulted by a group of Native Hawaiian and Asian men. When the initial trial ended in a hung jury, her mother, Grace Fortescue, along with two Navy men, kidnapped and murdered one of the accused, Joseph Kahahawai. They were convicted of manslaughter, not murder, and served only one hour in custody. The case drew national attention and highlighted racial tensions in pre-statehood Hawaii.
- Ripped from the pages of The Bad Seed and its adaptations.
- After learning the murder weapon was a Tanfoglio .380 Auto, Logan says he doubts they're dealing with a gang killing, as that kind of gun is too expensive for most gang bangers to be using for hits. Tanfoglio is a higher end Italian firearms company, their handguns are primarily designed for professional competition shooting, personal defense and for military use; the components for their guns are known for their high quality and are used by Israel Military Industries (IMI) in the guns they produce for the Israeli Armed Forces and Mossad, Israel's intelligence agency. Their personal defense models sell for around $1,200 and their competition models sell for over $2,000.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Kelly Bishop (Marian Borland) also worked together on three episodes of The Good Wife (2009) as Peter Florrick & Bea Wilson respectively.
Silence
S02E21 1992
- This episode marks Joanna Merlin's first appearance in the "Law & Order" franchise. In this episode, she plays defense attorney Carla Bowman, a character who also appears in Virus (1993). She then made a few other appearances in later seasons as defense attorney Deirdre Powell. She is best known for playing Judge Lena Petrovsky in 43 episodes of Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (1999).
- This episode appears to be based on several separate cases/incidents:
- The 1991 John C. Chenoweth case. Chenoweth was a Minnesota politician, executive director of the Minneapolis Municipal Employees Retirement Fund, and a victim of an anti-gay hate crime. Chenoweth was murdered by gunshot on the beach (a gay hangout area at the time) in Minneapolis, on August 10, 1991. 19-year-old Cord Draszt was seriously wounded in the same shooting. The murderer, Jay Thomas Johnson, who was also gay, had shot and killed another gay man in Loring Park 11 days earlier, on July 31, 1991. The victim of that crime was 21-year-old Joel Larson.
- The 1991 Victor Chang case. Chang was a Chinese-born Australian cardiac surgeon and a pioneer of modern heart transplantation in Australia. In 1991, Chang was murdered by two young men, Chew Seng (Ah Sung) Liew and Choon Tee (Phillip) Lim, in a failed extortion attempt.
- Partially ripped from the 1961 British neo-noir film Victim (1961).
- Ceretta and Logan ask if the blackmail calls were collect, since that's the only type inmates can make. Collect calls charge the recipient, once done through operators and now automated. They were common for payphones and long-distance calls. Prisons use them to cut costs and control who inmates can contact, with recipients told the inmate's name and facility before choosing to accept or refuse.
- Graeme Malcolm (Drotos) also played the role of a Hotel Manager in Cut (2004) (episode 15.06).
- Joanna Merlin has portrayed two different characters during the course of the series:
- QUOTE: Bowman (editor of the newspaper planning to out Vogel): "I'm not merely asserting MY rights, Mr. Stone. Freedom of the Press is the Public's right. If the press were fair game, Anita Hill would still be some unknown professor in Oklahoma".
- Reed Birney played three different characters over the course of the series:
- Barclay, a reporter from a gay magazine, tells EADA Stone that without full First Amendment protection for sources, Anita Hill's story might never have surfaced. Hill accused Supreme Court nominee Clarence Thomas of sexual harassment during his 1991 confirmation hearings. Though Thomas denied the allegations, he was narrowly confirmed 52-48 and remains on the Court as of 2025, having voted to overturn Roe v. Wade.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Joanna Merlin (Carla Bowman) also worked together on In Sickness (2011) (episode 2.21) as Peter Florrick & Loni Goslin respectively.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Reed Birney (Malcolm Barclay) also worked together on Battle of the Proxies (2012) (episode 4.10), as Peter Florrick & Lee Tripke respectively.
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Graeme Malcolm (Drotos) also worked together on Winning Ugly (2015) (episode 6.19), as Peter Florrick & Actor #2 respectively.
The Working Stiff
S02E22 1992
- This episode appears to be based on the following events:
- The 1989 "Keating Five" scandal and the subsequent savings and loan crisis. The scandal was part of the savings and loan crisis, involving five U.S. senators-Alan Cranston, Dennis DeConcini, John Glenn, John McCain, and Donald Riegle-accused of improperly pressuring regulators to ease scrutiny of Charles Keating's Lincoln Savings and Loan. Regulators backed off, fearing that it might fuel a major political controversy.
- The Michael Milken case. Milken, the 1980s "junk bond king," revolutionized corporate finance with leveraged buyouts but was convicted of securities and tax felonies in 1990. He served time in prison and was later pardoned by President Donald Trump in 2020.
- The 1986 Ivan Boesky case. Boesky was a former American stock trader who became infamous for his prominent role in an insider trading scandal that occurred in the United States during the mid-1980s. He was charged and pled guilty to insider trading, was fined a record $100 million, and later became an informant.
- The 1986 Bank of Credit and Commerce International (BCCI) money laundering scandal. The scandal revealed the BCCI as a global money-laundering hub tied to dictators, the Medellín Cartel, and terrorist groups. Raided in 1991, it earned the nickname "Bank of Crooks and Criminals International." Washington lawyer Clark Clifford was implicated but had charges dropped for health reasons; he and his partner later paid a $5 million settlement.
.- Inspired by the life of American Financer Asher Edelman.
- Inspired by the life of American businessman Carl Icahn.
- Assistant District Attorney Paul Robinette mentions "St. Eligius". This is a reference to St. Elsewhere (1982) whose hospital was called St. Eligius. Both Law & Order and St. Elsewhere aired on NBC.
- One of the characters mentions corporate raiders "like McFadden and Pickens". While McFadden is a character in this story, T. Boone Pickens is an actual businessman, primarily in petroleum, from Drumright, Oklahoma.
- Victor Slezak has played four different characters throughout the course of Law & Order:
- Chris Noth (Detective Mike Logan) & Victor Slezak (William Cousins) also worked together on the The Good Wife (2009) episode Lifeguard (2009) (episode 1.10), as Peter Florrick & the Palgrave Director respectively.
Generated Sep 17, 2026, 2:01:44 PM ET | Data scraped Aug 12, 2026, 3:52:15 PM ET